Equipment

Blender

A jug blender, a stick blender and a food processor look like three versions of the same appliance and are three different tools. Each is clearly better than the others at some jobs and clearly worse at others.

The three appliances

Jug blender
A tall jug and a fast blade at the bottom. Best at anything liquid — smoothies, soups, sauces, batters — because the shape circulates the contents past the blade. Poor at anything dry or thick, which just sits there.
Stick or immersion blender
A blade on a shaft you put into the pot. Blends soup in the pan with no transferring and no washing up. Less powerful and less smooth than a jug blender, and by far the most convenient.
Food processor
A wide bowl and a broad blade. Best at solids — chopping, pastry, breadcrumbs, hummus, pesto, grating with the disc attachments. Poor at thin liquids, which leak past the lid.
High-power blender
A jug blender with several times the motor. Genuinely produces smoother purées and can handle nuts, ice and fibrous vegetables. Expensive, loud, and only worth it if you use it constantly.
Which first
A stick blender, for most people. Cheap, small, and it does the commonest job — soup — better than the alternatives.

Blending hot liquids safely

This is the one part of using a blender where the consequence of getting it wrong is a burn, so it is worth stating plainly.

Getting better results

Why blade shape and jug shape matter

A jug blender works because the tall, narrow, often fluted jug forces the contents into a circulating pattern that keeps pulling new material down onto the blade. That only happens if there is enough liquid to flow. Put something thick in and it forms a dome above the blade, which spins in a pocket of air doing nothing — the familiar sight of a blender running loudly and blending nothing.

A food processor works the opposite way. Its bowl is wide and shallow and its blade is broad and set low, so it throws solids outwards against the wall and back in. Thin liquid in the same bowl simply rises up the side and out past the lid.

Neither shape is better. They are shaped for the two states of matter people put in them, which is why owning one and using it for both is the source of most blending disappointment.

Common questions

Can a stick blender replace a jug blender?

For soups and sauces, largely yes. For smoothies with frozen fruit or ice, no — it lacks the power and the jug shape.

Can I crush ice in a blender?

Only in one rated for it. Ice destroys blades and motors not built for the job.

Why is my soup not smooth?

Blend longer than feels necessary, and then sieve it. Fibrous vegetables — celery, leek, fennel — never fully break down.

Food processor or blender for hummus?

Food processor. Hummus is thick and would just sit above a blender blade.

Try this next