Ingredient

Sesame oil

There are two sesame oils and confusing them ruins dishes in both directions. Toasted sesame oil is dark, intensely aromatic, and a seasoning added at the end. Light or plain sesame oil is pale, mild, and a cooking fat. A recipe saying "sesame oil" almost always means the toasted one, and using it as a frying oil is a common and expensive mistake.

The two oils

Toasted / dark sesame oil
Pressed from roasted seeds. Deep amber-brown, powerfully nutty and aromatic. A finishing seasoning, used by the teaspoon. Its aroma compounds are volatile and heat destroys them, and it burns readily.
Light / plain sesame oil
Pressed from raw seeds. Pale yellow, mild, faintly nutty. A neutral cooking oil with a reasonably high smoke point, used across South Asia and the Middle East.
Gingelly or til oil
The Indian name, usually for a lightly toasted version, somewhere between the two. Used for cooking in South India.
Blended
Some bottles are toasted oil cut with a neutral oil. Cheaper, less aromatic, and a reasonable compromise for stir-frying.
How to tell
Colour. Dark amber means toasted and means seasoning. Pale yellow means a cooking oil.

Using toasted sesame oil

It is a seasoning. Treat it like a spice rather than like a fat.

Buying and keeping it

Good toasted sesame oil smells intensely of toasted sesame the moment the cap comes off. If it does not, it is old or it is blended.

Look for pure sesame oil on the label rather than a blend, unless a blend is what you want. Japanese and Korean brands are generally reliable and are worth the small premium over supermarket own-brand.

Both kinds go rancid — sesame oil is largely unsaturated — but toasted sesame oil is relatively stable because the roasting produces antioxidant compounds. It still deteriorates. Keep it in the fridge once opened if you use it slowly; it may cloud slightly in the cold, which is harmless and clears at room temperature.

Buy small bottles. A large bottle of toasted sesame oil used by the half-teaspoon will go stale long before it is finished.

What light sesame oil is actually for

The forgotten bottle, and it has a proper job of its own rather than being a lesser version of the toasted one.

Common questions

Can I fry in toasted sesame oil?

No — it burns and its flavour is destroyed. Use light sesame oil or a neutral oil, and add toasted sesame oil at the end.

Which one does my recipe mean?

Almost always the toasted one, unless it specifies a quantity large enough to fry in.

What can I substitute?

Nothing exactly. Tahini thinned with a neutral oil gets you a sesame note without the roasted aroma. Toasted sesame seeds crushed into oil is closer.

Does it need refrigerating?

Not strictly, and it helps if you use it slowly. Cloudiness in the cold is normal.

Why does my stir-fry taste burnt?

Possibly toasted sesame oil used as a frying fat. Add it after the pan comes off the heat.

Try this next